[ID3 Dev] ID3v2.5

[Michal Vician]

Nice attempt :-) Some things sounds really good and I think the new tag
version should be done this way - quote: "Simplicity is a good thing...".

------------
My comments:

>- no extended header
>- no padding
>- no footer
* agreed

>- encoding is apply to all metadata (all frames)
* I don't think this is good idea. I think that encoding should be
declared for each frame separately.

>- all metadata are syncronized or codified in such format that this will
> not alter mp3 frames, including ID3v2.5 Metadata Identifier
* Agreed. But there sould be preserved the way of synchonizing v2.4. I
mean, it should be possible to synchronize each frame and header
separately (don't do the same mistake as in v2.3)...

>- there is only text and objects (binary) frames, put in it what you wont
> and name it how you wont. For text frames will be apply metadata encoding,
> for binary not.
* OK

>- structure version (tag version), will be in ID3v2.5 Identifier
* What Identifier?

>- encoding is applying only on frames, text frames!
>- no tag restrictions
>- no syncsafe integers, no!
* agreed


> ID3v2.5 Frame:
>
> - Full Frame Size
> - Frame Name (at end is a null terminated char, so frame name is not
> fixed)
> - IsBinary
> - Content
* amazing :-)

> Thats all, from my perspective. Simplicity is a good thing, is you think
> that thi is a good idea or not please comment. Anyway i thinking about
> sizes... and native frames.
Yes. I think that the idea is really good. I hope others think the same.
However, there is much to discuss about.
I also think that simplicity is the way :-)

Best regards
Miso



> D:\Music\Albums\Electronica\Goa Trance\The History Of Goa Trance\09. The
> Muses Rapt - Spiritual Healing.mp3 :
>
>       -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
>           content metadata
>       -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
>           audio content
>       -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
>
>   content metadata:
>
>       -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
>           ID3v2.5 Identifier | Full Metadata Size | Text Frames Encoding
>  ->
>           ---------------------------  -------------------------------
> -----------------------------
>
>   Changes (from ID3v2.4):
>
>       - no extended header
>       - no padding
>       - no footer
>       - encoding is apply to all metadata (all frames)
>       - all metadata are syncronized or codified in such format that this
> will not alter
>         mp3 frames, including ID3v2.5 Metadata Identifier
>       - there is only text and objects (binary) frames, put in it what you
> wont and name it
>         how you wont. For text frames will be apply metadata encoding, for
> binary not.
>       - structure version (tag version), will be in ID3v2.5 Identifier.
>       - encoding is applying only on frames, text frames!
>       - no tag restrictions
>       - no syncsafe integers, no!
>       -
>
>
>           -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
>   ->     Frames ...
>       -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
>
>   ID3v2.5 Frame:
>
>       Full Frame Size
>       Frame Name (at end is a null terminated char, so frame name is not
> fixed)
>       IsBinary
>       Content
>
>
>   Thats all, from my perspective. Simplicity is a good thing, is you think
> that thi is a good idea or not please comment. Anyway i thinking about
> sizes... and native frames.
>
>
> ---------------------------------
> To help you stay safe and secure online, we've developed the all new
> Yahoo! Security Centre.


---
Michal Vician
id3v2 at audiott.com
http://www.audiott.com/


---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: id3v2-unsubscribe at id3.org
For additional commands, e-mail: id3v2-help at id3.org